The Cello Suites: J. S. Bach, Pablo Casals, and the Search for a Baroque Masterpiece
RRP: $24.00Our Price: $12.99 (subject to change)- ISBN13: 9780802119292
- Condition: New
- Notes: BUY WITH CONFIDENCE, Over one million books sold! 98% Positive feedback. Compare our books, prices and service to the competition. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed
Reviews
Energetic, yet flawedReview date: 2010-08-02 Rating: 6 out of 10Mr. Siblin "3 in one" technique of using the cello suites as a fulcrum upon which to biography JS Bach, Pablo Casals, and to some degree, autobiography of himself. The biographies on Back and Casals are well written, particularly that of Casals, yet suffer from omission of timeline dates and ages that put life events in perspective. However, Mr. Siblin injects a fair amount of narcissism in his view of Bach's music, particularly a number of pages dealing with the uncomfortable anti-Semitism of Bach's lyrics in an Easter Mass, even though the cello suites themselves do not have lyrics. Rather than narcissistic rants on how "difficult" it is for the author to play cello and sing Bach, I would have liked more insight into the Suites themselves from a performance perspective -- how did virtusosi such as Casals and Rostropovich deal with these masterworks differently?
Overall, a good book, a great choice for a weekend summer read.100% BachReview date: 2010-06-14 Rating: 10 out of 10It's so wonderfu! I'm writing an extensive paper about the suites, and Siblin's book is by much the best source of information I've come across...Misleading title, decent readReview date: 2010-05-24 Rating: 8 out of 10Pablo Casals, the great Catalan cellist, happened to purchase a second-hand copy of the 1866 edition of the Bach cello suites (edited by the great Leipzig cellist Friedrich Wilhelm Grutzmacher, who died in 1903) in a bookstore in Barcelona in 1890. There are three 18th century original manuscripts of the Bach cello suites, none of them in Bach's handwriting but all three are contemporaneous with Bach. At least one of them was copied out by Bach's wife, not surprising since she was his copyist. While the title of this book is "the Search for a Baroque Masterpiece," in fact no one was searching for the cello suites, which had never been lost (there are actually fifty-some editions of these suites). Casals did not "search" for the suites, nor did he "find" them. Perhaps in order to plump up some mystery issue to keep readers turning the page, the author does not make this clear until you are far into the book. I found this annoying, as if the author didn't trust the reader to decide that the intertwined lives of Bach and Casals would be interesting enough to hold your attention. In fact, the book has a wealth of interesting details about Bach's life and personality and brings Casals deservedly back into the public eye. Unfortunately, the author's description of the suites themselves is long on descriptive adjectives but short on actual musical interpretation or understanding. The cellist Walter Joachim understandably told the author to learn the cello if he really wanted to understand the cello suites; what he really meant was "try to understand something about classical music." It's admirable that a pop critic became a fan of this music but this quote sums up his lack of basic musical knowledge: "Bach implies harmony.... He hints at it, suggests it, plants the seed of harmony." (p. 56). Clearly some basic music analytical skills are lacking here. In any event, worth reading for the stories of two great men and their times.A Modern MasterpieceReview date: 2010-05-23 Rating: 10 out of 10In Siblin's first book, there is an underlying air of mystery and impressive bibliographic research. The author adds an unusual aspect to enhance his fine writing: learning to play the cello himself. But you don't have to be a musician to enjoy reading THE CELLO SUITES: J. S. BACH, PABLO CASALS, AND THE SEARCH FOR A BAROQUE MASTERPIECE.
Product Details/Specifications
Authors:
Eric Siblin
Recording label: Atlantic Monthly Press Manufacturer: Atlantic Monthly PressEAN: 9780802119292Binding: HardcoverDewey decimal number: 787.41858ISBN: 0802119298Number of items: 1Number of pages: 336Publication date: 2009-12-15Language: English (Unknown)
Language: English (Original Language)
Language: English (Published) Similar Products
Add to Cart